Wisconsin Senate Majority Leader Devin LeMahieu declared at the end of 2025 that his Republican colleagues “delivered the second-largest income tax cut in state history to put more money in Wisconsin families’ pockets for gas and groceries.”
That, he claimed, flies in the face of Democrats who want to increase taxes to pay for a “radical agenda nobody can afford.”
I’m not sure what this radical agenda is — helping young parents afford child care perhaps? — but a lot of folks who paid their property taxes last month aren’t convinced that the Legislature’s actions have put more money into their pockets to pay for gas and groceries.
That goes for the homeowners whose bills skyrocketed and the renters whose rents will go up because the owners of their apartments had to shell out a lot more money, too.
In fact, from all that I’ve been reading from around the state, it’s LeMahieu and his minions who have forced Wisconsin school districts to beg their property owners to give them the money they need to run their schools.
Here in Madison, the public school system’s share accounted for about 90% of the roughly $800 increase on the average home. That was due, of course, to the $607 million referendums Madison School District voters approved to build and repair its schools and give staff pay raises.
But Madison isn’t an outlier. Property taxpayers throughout the state experienced the sticker shock when their tax bills arrived just before Christmas.
Six school leaders from Milwaukee and southeast Wisconsin collaborated on a guest column for the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel at the end of the year to explain the predicament.
“State elected officials have knowingly passed the buck to homeowners in the form of local property tax increases when they chose not to adequately fund the state-controlled school finance formula in the current state budget,” they wrote.
“The state legislature has abandoned Wisconsin’s long-standing commitment to funding two-thirds of public education, shifting more of the cost onto local property taxpayers,” the column added. “Lawmakers provided $0 in new general school aid over the biennium, a first in modern Wisconsin history. As a result, the majority of districts will receive less state support this year, leaving school boards with only two choices: raise local property taxes or make massive cuts to essential educational programs.”
Consequently, 63% of the state’s school districts have had to make the painful choice in the last three years to ask voters to bail them out of impossible financial holes.
The six educators — Superintendents Laurie Burgos of Shorewood, Matthew Joynt of Mequon-Thiensville, Deborah Kerr of St. Francis, Jeffrey Weiss of Kenosha, Kenosha’s board president, Todd Allan Price, and Cathy Olig of the Southeastern School Alliance — answered the question: Why all the referendums?
“Because state investment has not kept up with inflation, and the cost of running a school district has only increased, with double-digit increases in health insurance, utility costs, and the costs of offering highly desired programming such as construction, nursing, and engineering career pathways,” they declared.
And let’s not forget the money being siphoned from public school districts to support the state’s ever-expanding voucher system, a once altruistic idea to allow poor families to transfer their children from failing schools to private ones. That has now ballooned into a behemoth that allows the wealthy to siphon taxpayer dollars to send their kids to private schools they once paid for themselves.
LeMahieu’s colleagues have been pushing choice expansion during the 14 years they have controlled the Legislature.
As the School Board in western Wisconsin’s Kickapoo School District, with fewer than 500 students from kindergarten through high school, wrote the Legislature in 2024, “Your school voucher programs are killing us.”
The board had to send $113,000 of its state education aid to support 11 students who had opted to attend a private school instead. That was a huge blow to a small rural district.
What’s so infuriating about the Legislature’s reluctance to assist the public school system is that it’s sitting on a $4.7 billion budget surplus. The GOP leadership of LaMehieu and Assembly Speaker Robin Vos want to use that money for “meaningful income tax cuts.” If Gov. Tony Evers won’t go along, then the money won’t be spent.
Meanwhile, the legislative leadership is willing to allow the most regressive tax of all — the property tax — to continue out of control, in turn causing harm to elderly homeowners on fixed incomes and making rents and homeownership even more unaffordable for younger people.
With any luck, those property tax bills will serve as a wake-up call that Wisconsin is long overdue for a change in its legislative leadership.
Dave Zweifel is editor emeritus of The Capital Times. dz******@*****on.com, 608-252-6410 and on Twitter @DaveZweifel.
Share your opinion on this topic by sending a letter to the editor to tc******@*****on.com. Include your full name, hometown and phone number. Your name and town will be published. The phone number is for verification purposes only. Please keep your letter to 250 words or less.

