State lawmakers are putting the future of Missouri taxation in voter’s hands this primary season.
Amendment 5, one of four amendments on Tuesday’s ballots, would require Missouri legislators to begin phasing out the state income tax and grant them permission to make increases to sales and use taxes to compensate.
Constitutional Amendment No. 5 is worded on the ballot as follows:
“Shall the Missouri Constitution be amended to:
require legislative phase-out of the individual state income tax based on revenue growth, and authorize the expansion of sales and use taxes;
curtail constitutional limits on taxing goods and services; and
require local tax rate cuts without reducing school funding if local sales tax revenue increases?”
If Amendment 5 passes, it would allow the state to impose sales taxes on all goods and services. Certain exceptions could be made for industries like agriculture and health care, however none are specified in the passed legislation. The current sales tax is 4.225 percent.
The proposed taxation change has proven to be one of the most controversial issues this election cycle. Republican lawmakers advocating for the amendment say it will provide economic stimulus for Missouri and place it on the same track as other states that have successfully repealed the income tax. Detractors, however, view the amendment as too vague, with no clearly defined plan for how the lost income tax revenue will be replaced.
Camden County Presiding Commissioner Ike Skelton called Amendment 5 a “Let’s pass it to see what’s in it” piece of legislation during a forum hosted by the News Tribune on July 22. Skelton is running as a Republican for the Missouri Senate’s 6th district.
“I’m totally opposed to Amendment 5, but I don’t necessarily believe that income tax shouldn’t be reduced,” he said. “And oh, by the way, the government can do that right now without your permission. What they need permission to do is to be able to raise your taxes, and that’s what they’re asking for.”
Skelton suggested phasing out personal property taxes for items like cars and livestock would have a more positive impact for Missourians than repealing income tax.
Another Republican on Tuesday’s ballot, Scott Spencer, says he is broadly in favor of enacting tax cuts but cannot support the amendment.
“Amendment 5 is just open-ended legislation — it’s just bad policy. When we’re asked to vote on a constitutional amendment, it needs to be narrowly focused and well-defined,” he said.
Spencer is running for District 60 in the House of Representatives (representing Jefferson City). Based on his experience talking to voters around Jefferson City, he is skeptical Amendment 5 will get enough votes in support to pass.
“I’m on my second pair of tennis shoes knocking on doors, and I could (count) on both my hands the people that are supporting it. It’s overwhelmingly not popular,” Spencer said.
Around the nation, there are nine states that have no form of income tax: Alaska, Florida, Nevada, South Dakota, Texas, Wyoming, Washington, New Hampshire and Tennessee. Lawmakers will look to these states for replacing the income tax, which makes up more than 60 percent of Missouri’s revenue, should Amendment 5 pass.
MO Tax Relief Now, a prominent advocacy group, has been one of the loudest supporters for Amendment 5 this election cycle. The group pushes for a variety of legislation that offers tax reductions for Missourians, like the senior property tax freeze.
One of the group’s biggest messages to voters has been that Amendment 5 will not lead to an increase in tax payments.
“One of the biggest misconceptions is that they’ve been told that their sales taxes are going to be 15 and 20 percent. And that’s just not true,” said Dennis Ganahl, founder and CEO of MO Tax Relief Now. “You’ve got states that surround Missouri that have six and a half, six percent … like Kansas I think is at six and a half percent, something like that. So we would never have a sales tax that would be higher than Kansas. That wouldn’t make any sense.”
Under the 1980 Hancock Amendment, Missouri is not permitted to impose new or increased taxes without voter approval. It also has a revenue cap tap tied to total personal income. Those on opposite ends of the issue have argued whether Amendment 5 is a Hancock violation.
“Constitutionally, this legislature can never change the tax code by one penny more than it is to offset the income tax refund that Missourians will get. So there is a definite safeguard there to make sure Missourians are protected,” Gov. Mike Kehoe said in a July 23 Facebook post.
Ganahl believes Missouri is most comparable to Tennessee, which phased its income tax out completely by 2021. Tennessee’s economy has grown in the last half decade while, according to Ganahl, Missouri’s has been stagnant for decades. He believes Amendment 5 will stimulate the economy by making the state more attractive to incoming businesses.
“They had a plan in place –‘This is how we’re going to build the Tennessee economy.’ And we don’t have a plan. We’re just kind of wandering around here in the dark, arguing about this and arguing about that,” Ganahl said. “And even the opposition on Amendment 5 (saying) this is a bad plan — well, what’s your plan? They don’t have a plan. Their only plan is to make you pay income tax the rest of your life.”
